The Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel Restaurant photoThe Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel Exterior photoThe Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel Exterior photo
Book on our site
Up to 10% cheaper
than Booking.com
Check rooms and rates
From341US$ /night
Check-in
19Apr2026Select date
Check-out
20Apr2026Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Key details

About the Island Hotel

22 Atlantic Walk, Fire Island Pines, New York, United States, NY 11782
-
Close to the Fire Island National Seashore
Perfect
9.3
8.6
/10
3.7
3.9
/5

The Madison Fire Island Pines - A pet-friendly guesthouse with a sun terrace, massage services, and pool or garden views

The Madison Fire Island Pines, a 3-star guesthouse (9.2/10 on Booking.com), features double rooms and suites offering pool or garden views, air conditioning, and free Wi-Fi. A continental breakfast is available each morning at The Madison Fire Island Pines. The property includes a sun terrace and massage services, with notable nearby landmarks like Fire Island National Seashore (1 km) and Barrett Beach Park (3 km). Long Island MacArthur Airport is the nearest, located 10 km away. Ironing facilities and a terrace are available in some units, with select rooms including TVs.

Pros

The pet-friendly policy accommodates travelers with animals.

The sun terrace provides a space to relax with pool and garden views.

Massage services offer an additional leisure option.

Free Wi-Fi is accessible in all rooms.

Cons

Long Island MacArthur Airport is the nearest, requiring a 10 km commute.

Some destinations, like Riverhead, are 50 km away.

View all

Select your room type

The Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals
Standard Double Room
2 persons
2 Single beds
Deluxe Double Room
2 persons
2 Single beds
Deluxe King Room
2 persons
2 Single beds
Standard Single Room
2 persons
1 King-size bed
Click button to see more rooms
Show all rooms
Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Facilities

The Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences
Facilities: Perfect
9.2/10Review score

General

  • No smoking on site
  • Pets allowed
  • Adults only

Spa & Leisure

  • Heated swimming pool
  • Outdoor swimming pool
  • Beach umbrellas
  • Sun loungers
  • Sun terrace

Room features

  • Free Wi-Fi in rooms
  • Air conditioning
  • Terrace
  • Ironing facilities
Show more

The Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel Location

22 Atlantic Walk, Fire Island Pines, New York, United States, NY 11782
Map view
22 Atlantic Walk, Fire Island Pines, New York, United States, NY 11782
Nearby
Pavilion
1200 ft
Restaurants
Pines Bistro and Martini Bar
1100 ft
36 Fire Island Blvd
Canteen
1300 ft
Harbor Walk
Explore Fire Island Pines
Local Highlights
Top Attractions
Activities
Dining
Entertainment
Fire Island National Seashore
15 minutes' walk
A protected natural area featuring pristine beaches and diverse wildlife, ideal for nature enthusiasts.
Talisman-Barrett Beach
10 minutes' drive
A scenic beach perfect for sunbathing and swimming, known for its tranquil atmosphere and picturesque views.
Barrett Beach Park
10 minutes' drive
This serene park offers beach access and picnic areas, ideal for families and outdoor relaxation.
Sailors Haven Visitor Center
10 minutes' drive
Provides information about the island's natural and historical sites, featuring exhibits and a stunning beach.
Kayaking Tours
10 minutes' drive
Rent kayaks nearby for a thrilling adventure on the water, suitable for all skill levels.
Yoga Classes
5 minutes' walk
Join relaxing yoga sessions at the beach, perfect for restoring balance amidst stunning natural scenery.
Pines Bistro and Martini Bar
4 minutes' walk
Offers upscale dining with a sophisticated atmosphere; try their signature martinis and fresh seafood.
Canteen
5 minutes' walk
Casual eatery known for delicious burgers and local favorites; great for families and quick bites.
Ice Palace Nightclub
5 minutes' drive
A popular nightlife venue featuring drag shows and themed parties; an iconic spot for evening fun.
Pavilion
5 minutes' walk
A lively beachfront bar with weekly events and live entertainment, perfect for a fun, social atmosphere.
Getting around
City Centre
Fire Island Pines3 min  ·  700 ft
Airports
Long Island MacArthur (ISP)14 min  ·  5.7 mi
Republic (FRG)50 min  ·  20.7 mi
Want to see Exclusive Early Island Booking Rates?
Get exlusive rates right now!
Check Rates
Property information and rules
Check-in
from 15:30-21:00
Check-out
until 12 pm
Guest Parking
No parking available.
Internet
Wireless internet is available in the hotel rooms for free.
Breakfast
The hotel The Madison Fire Island Pines serves a full breakfast for free. 
Children & extra beds
There are no extra beds provided in a room. 
Pets
Pets are allowed on request.
Number of rooms:
9

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback about The Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel from previous guests about their experience.
Review score
Based on 23 verified reviews
9.1/10
Perfect
88%
Recommend
Cleanliness
9.5/10
Comfort
9.0/10
Facilities
9.2/10
Location
10.0/10
Staff
9.4/10
Value for money
8.1/10
Pros
Gorgeous rooms
Excellent service
Cons
Unfriendly staff
Poor cleanliness
Guest reviews
based on 14 reviews
9.3/10
No reviews yet on our siteUnfortunately, our guests have not yet left any reviews for this hotel, but you can read reviews from Booking.com.
Open reviews
FAQs
About The Madison Fire Island Pines
How far is The Madison Fire Island Pines from Long Island MacArthur Airport?
The Madison Fire Island Pines is located 10 km from Long Island MacArthur Airport.
What type of accommodation does The Madison Fire Island Pines offer?
The Madison Fire Island Pines provides adults-only accommodation with garden and pool views.
What amenities are available at The Madison Fire Island Pines?
The Madison Fire Island Pines features an outdoor swimming pool, sun terrace, and free WiFi.
What dining option is available at The Madison Fire Island Pines?
Guests can enjoy a complimentary continental breakfast at The Madison Fire Island Pines.
What is the check-in and check-out policy at The Madison Fire Island Pines?
Check-in at The Madison Fire Island Pines is from 15:30, and check-out is required by 12:00.
Is there a swimming pool at The Madison Fire Island Pines?
The Madison Fire Island Pines features a heated outdoor swimming pool that is open year-round.
What can guests do for relaxation at The Madison Fire Island Pines?
Guests at The Madison Fire Island Pines can enjoy massage services as part of their relaxation options.
What nearby attractions are located close to The Madison Fire Island Pines?
Nearby attractions include Pavilion Beach (0.5 km), Talisman-Barrett Beach (3 km), and the Sunken Forest (4 km).

Next best alternative

Consider them for your next trip.
Check-in
19Apr2026Select date
Check-out
20Apr2026Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room