Top 1 Island Hotels in Fire Island Pines, 2026

Fire Island Pines features beautiful beaches like the Fire Island National Seashore, lively nightlife at the Pines Sun and Surf, and stunning views from the Lighthouse Beach. You can find a range of fire island hotels, from cozy beachfront cottages to stylish modern inns. These accommodations often offer amenities like pool access, breathtaking ocean views, and easy beach access, each carefully selected based on guest reviews for your enjoyment. Book early, especially in the summer, to secure your stay, and consider using the ferry for easy travel around the island.

1-1 out of 1

Sort by:

Price: low to high
Price: high to low
Guest rating: high to low
Popularity: high to low

The Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel

Map200 yd from City Centre1500 yd from Fire Island National Seashore

FromUS$ 341 /nightSelect

Price range for hotels in Fire Island Pines

A world of island accommodation options awaits, from budget-friendly beach stays to luxurious overwater retreats, with prices suited to every traveler's tropical dream.

⬆️ The highest price

US$ 341

⬇️ The lowest price

US$ 341

💸 Average price for

3-star hotels

US$ 310

Key Information About Hotels in Fire Island Pines

This guide summarizes key details about hotels in Fire Island Pines, evaluating one property to provide crucial facts for travelers seeking accommodations in this unique coastal area.

Typical nightly rates range from $250 to $450 USD.

There is 1 primary hotel property available.

Peak season spans from late June to early September.

Local taxes and fees can add around 15% to your bill.

The hotel is approximately 0.8 kilometers from the ferry terminal and 1 kilometer from the beach.