Top 15 Island Hotels in Montauk, 2026

Montauk boasts the stunning Montauk Point Lighthouse, the tranquil beaches at Ditch Plains, and the vibrant atmosphere of the Montauk Marina. You can enjoy activities like surfing and fishing along its scenic coastline. For your stay, check out luxury hotels like Gurney's Montauk Resort & Spa or beachfront hotels like the Montauk Beach House, each offering unique experiences by the sea. This site presents an exclusive selection of top beach hotels, ensuring you find the right fit. Book in advance for July and August, when the town is most crowded, and consider renting a bike for easy travel around the charming areas.

1-15 out of 15

Sort by:

Price: low to high
Price: high to low
Guest rating: high to low
Popularity: high to low

8.0

Great

The Montauk Soundview Hotel

Map2.8 mi from City Centre1.2 mi from Gin Beach

FromUS$ 407 /nightSelect

8.6

Great

Breakers Montauk Motel

Map900 yd from City Centre400 yd from Second House Museum

FromUS$ 183 /nightSelect

8.4

Great

Hartman'S Briney Breezes Beach Resort

Map1300 yd from City Centre900 yd from Second House Museum

FromUS$ 305 /nightSelect

8.2

Great

Gurney'S Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

Map2.4 mi from City Centre1.0 mi from Lee Koppelman Nature Preserve

FromUS$ 275 /nightSelect

8.4

Great

Montauk Yacht Club

Map2.6 mi from City Centre1.0 mi from Theodore Roosevelt County Park

FromUS$ 329 /nightSelect

8.0

Great

Marram

Map1600 yd from City Centre1000 yd from Kirk Park Beach

FromUS$ 903 /nightSelect

8.2

Great

Montauk Blue Hotel

Map1100 yd from City Centre300 yd from Kirk Park Beach

FromUS$ 130 /nightSelect

8.4

Great

Ocean Surf Resort

Map900 yd from City Centre100 yd from Kirk Park Beach

FromUS$ 470 /nightSelect

8.4

Great

The Surf Club Resort

Map1500 yd from City Centre900 yd from Kirk Park Beach

FromUS$ 300 /nightSelect

8.6

Great

Beach Plum Resort

Map800 yd from City Centre300 yd from Second House Museum

FromUS$ 322 /nightSelect

8.4

Great

Driftwood Resort On The Ocean

Map4.5 mi from City Centre

FromUS$ 156 /nightSelect

8.2

Great

Royal Atlantic Beach Resort

Map1200 yd from City Centre500 yd from Kirk Park Beach

FromUS$ 113 /nightSelect

8.6

Great

Beachcomber Resort At Montauk

Map1000 yd from City Centre600 yd from Second House Museum

FromUS$ 215 /nightSelect

8.4

Great

Hero Beach Club

Map700 yd from City Centre200 yd from Montauk Park

FromUS$ 260 /nightSelect

8.2

Great

A Wave Inn - Montauk

Map1000 yd from City Centre300 yd from Kirk Park Beach

FromUS$ 138 /nightSelect

Price range for hotels in Montauk

A world of island accommodation options awaits, from budget-friendly beach stays to luxurious overwater retreats, with prices suited to every traveler's tropical dream.

⬆️ The highest price

US$ 903

⬇️ The lowest price

US$ 113

💸 Average price for

5-star hotels

US$ 324

4-star hotels

US$ 481

3-star hotels

US$ 230

Best hotels in Montauk

Based on guest reviews over the last 12 months

Beachfront Bliss:

Royal Atlantic Beach Resort

Stylish Boutique Retreat:

Gurney'S Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

Family Friendly Fun:

Beach Plum Resort

Charming Coastal Escape:

A Wave Inn - Montauk

Luxury on the Water:

Montauk Yacht Club

Tranquil Nature Retreat:

The Montauk Soundview

Home Away From Home:

Driftwood Resort On The Ocean

Vintage Ocean Vibes:

Beachcomber Resort At Montauk

Active Adventure Hub:

Hero Beach Club

FAQs about hotels in Montauk

We hope these answers help you plan your island trip

Which hotels offer unique views in Montauk?

The Surf Club Resort and The Montauk Soundview both offer stunning ocean views, making them ideal for picturesque stays.

What are the cheapest hotel options in Montauk?

Cheaper options include A Wave Inn - Montauk and Driftwood Resort On The Ocean, with average nightly rates starting around $150 to $200 in the off-peak season.

Essential Hotel Facts for Montauk Travelers

This guide evaluates 15 hotels in Montauk, providing essential information on pricing, peak seasons, local taxes, and key attractions for travelers looking to plan their stay.

Typical nightly rates range from $200 to $600 USD.

Local tax/fees amount to 12.5%.

Peak travel seasons are June through August.

Most hotels are within 5 km of Montauk Point Lighthouse.

Book 3-6 months in advance for best rates.