Top 2 Island Hotels in Shelter Island Heights, 2026

Shelter Island Heights offers spots like Crescent Beach for sunbathing and the popular Sunset Beach for dining and drinks. You can check out the historic Shelter Island Lighthouse and enjoy kayaking at Silver Beach. This area is known for its charming waterfront views and laid-back vibe. Hotels here range from cozy inns to luxurious waterfront properties, each promising excellent amenities and personalized experiences. Booking through this site provides a carefully selected list of hotels that suit your preferences. For the best deals, consider off-peak times and book early, as transport around the island is easy with bike rentals.

1-2 out of 2

Sort by:

Price: low to high
Price: high to low
Guest rating: high to low
Popularity: high to low

8.6

Great

Shelter Island House Hotel Shelter Island Heights

Map1500 yd from City Centre1800 yd from Dering Harbor Marina

FromUS$ 569 /nightSelect

8.6

Great

Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach Shelter Island Heights

Map1400 yd from City Centre1700 yd from Dering Harbor Marina

FromUS$ 262 /nightSelect

Price range for hotels in Shelter Island Heights

A world of island accommodation options awaits, from budget-friendly beach stays to luxurious overwater retreats, with prices suited to every traveler's tropical dream.

⬆️ The highest price

US$ 569

⬇️ The lowest price

US$ 262

💸 Average price for

4-star hotels

US$ 395

Best hotels in Shelter Island Heights

Based on guest reviews over the last 12 months

Beachside Bliss:

Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach

Charming Retreats:

Shelter Island House

FAQs about hotels in Shelter Island Heights

We hope these answers help you plan your island trip

Which hotels in Shelter Island Heights are best for families?

Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach is a great option for families, featuring family-friendly amenities such as spacious rooms and easy beach access. It's ideal for activities with children.

Are there hotels in Shelter Island Heights with unique views?

Both properties, such as Shelter Island House, offer scenic views of the surrounding area, including gardens and beach vistas, which enhance the guest experience.

Which hotel is recommended for couples in Shelter Island Heights?

Shelter Island House is particularly favored by couples for its romantic atmosphere and serene location, making it an excellent retreat for a getaway.

What is the cheapest hotel option available in Shelter Island Heights?

The Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach offers competitive pricing starting at around $150 per night, especially during the off-peak season, making it the more economical choice.

Hotel Insights for Shelter Island Heights

This guide evaluates 2 hotels in Shelter Island Heights, offering practical information about pricing, peak seasons, and nearby attractions to assist travelers in making informed accommodation choices.

Typical nightly rates range from $150 to $400.

There are 2 hotels evaluated in the area.

Peak travel season is from late June to early September.

Local taxes and fees can add about 12-15% to your bill.

Both hotels are approximately 1.5 km from the Shelter Island Ferry.