Top 1 Island Hotels in Sag Harbor, 2026

Sag Harbor showcases the historic Whaling Museum and the vibrant Main Street, along with the picturesque Havens Beach and the serene Sag Harbor Cove. This charming town offers numerous cozy hotels and vacation rentals, such as the Bay Street Hotel with its waterfront views and easy access to local restaurants. You can find a selection of hand-picked hotels that focus on comfort and unique local experiences on this site. When booking, consider visiting in the summer for warm beach days or during the fall for peaceful getaways, and explore by bike or on foot.

1-1 out of 1

Sort by:

Price: low to high
Price: high to low
Guest rating: high to low
Popularity: high to low

8.4

Great

Faraway Sag Harbor Hotel

Map800 yd from City Centre500 yd from Off the Rocker

FromUS$ 219 /nightSelect

Price range for hotels in Sag Harbor

A world of island accommodation options awaits, from budget-friendly beach stays to luxurious overwater retreats, with prices suited to every traveler's tropical dream.

⬆️ The highest price

US$ 219

⬇️ The lowest price

US$ 219

💸 Average price for

4-star hotels

US$ 199

Essential Hotel Information for Sag Harbor

This guide provides critical information about hotels in Sag Harbor, evaluating 10 properties to help travelers make informed decisions for their stay.

Typical nightly prices range from $150-$500 USD.

There are 10 hotels available in Sag Harbor.

Peak travel seasons are summer months and holidays.

Local occupancy tax is 3% plus a $2 nightly fee.

Most hotels are within 1-2 km of Main Street and the harbor.