Top 5 Island Hotels in Garden City, 2026

Garden City is home to the beautiful parks of Tanglewood Park, the breathtaking scenery at the community lake, and the fun-filled entertainment at the Garden City Casino. You can explore art galleries and local shops in uptown Garden City. The available hotels range from cozy villas to elegant downtown suites, chosen for their comfort and positive reviews. These unique spots offer local experiences that bring you closer to the city. Book your stay in advance, especially around the summer festival season, and consider using public transport for easy access to attractions.

1-5 out of 5

Sort by:

Price: low to high
Price: high to low
Guest rating: high to low
Popularity: high to low

8.2

Great

Garden City Hotel

Map700 yd from City Centre200 yd from Garden City Station

FromUS$ 225 /nightSelect

8.4

Great

Hyatt Place Garden City

Map1.7 mi from City Centre600 yd from Roosevelt Field

FromUS$ 149 /nightSelect

8.2

Great

Residence Inn Long Island Garden City

Map1.1 mi from City Centre600 yd from Roosevelt Field

FromUS$ 739 /nightSelect

8.4

Great

Hampton Inn By Hilton Garden City Long Island

Map1.6 mi from City Centre500 yd from Roosevelt Field

FromUS$ 149 /nightSelect

8.4

Great

La Quinta By Wyndham Garden City

Map1.7 mi from City Centre900 yd from Cradle of Aviation Museum

FromUS$ 115 /nightSelect

Price range for hotels in Garden City

A world of island accommodation options awaits, from budget-friendly beach stays to luxurious overwater retreats, with prices suited to every traveler's tropical dream.

⬆️ The highest price

US$ 739

⬇️ The lowest price

US$ 115

💸 Average price for

5-star hotels

US$ 204

4-star hotels

US$ 135

3-star hotels

US$ 323

Best hotels in Garden City

Based on guest reviews over the last 12 months

Modern Comfort on the Go:

Hyatt Place Garden City

Budget-Friendly Stay:

La Quinta By Wyndham Garden City

Charming Hospitality Experience:

Hampton Inn By Hilton Garden City Long Island

Elegant Luxury Retreat:

Garden City Hotel

Extended Stay Convenience:

Residence Inn Long Island Garden City

FAQs about hotels in Garden City

We hope these answers help you plan your island trip

How many hotel properties are located in Garden City, and which are top-rated?

Garden City features five hotel properties. The top-rated include Garden City Hotel and Residence Inn Long Island Garden City, favored for their amenities and guest satisfaction.

Which hotels offer family-friendly amenities in Garden City?

Hampton Inn By Hilton Garden City Long Island and Residence Inn Long Island Garden City are good options for families, offering spacious rooms, kitchen facilities, and proximity to parks.

What hotels have unique views in Garden City?

The Garden City Hotel often provides guests with scenic views of the surrounding gardens. Additionally, Residence Inn Long Island Garden City offers pleasant views from many of its suites.

Which hotels in Garden City are best for couples?

The Garden City Hotel is ideal for couples, featuring upscale accommodations and a full-service spa. Hyatt Place Garden City is also a solid choice with a modern atmosphere and convenient dining options.

What is the cheapest hotel option in Garden City?

La Quinta By Wyndham Garden City typically offers the most affordable rates, with averages around $140 USD per night. It provides essential amenities and convenience without breaking the bank.

Essential Hotel Insights for Garden City

This guide provides analytical information on 5 hotels in Garden City, helping travelers make informed decisions about their accommodations, considering factors like pricing and proximity to local attractions.

Typical nightly rates range from $100 to $200.

Garden City has 5 hotel options for visitors.

Peak travel seasons include summer months and holiday weekends.

Expect local taxes and fees totaling about 12%.

Most hotels are within 5 km of the Garden City Shopping Center.